Image by DC Studio on Magnific

The Learning, Teaching and Assessment with AI series continues. Here follows Exercise 03 by Professor Derek Yu (Department of Economics) on how different approaches to using AI tools such as ChatGPT can meaningfully affect student learning outcomes in Economics. This example demonstrates how the quality of prompting significantly influences the usefulness of AI-generated study materials, particularly when students are under resource constraints.  

Context: Using AI as a Study Support Tool Under Resource Constraints
Isabella and Jabulani are both first-year Microeconomics students who have unfortunately lost their textbooks just before an upcoming tutorial test. They are unable to purchase replacement copies immediately, and the library copies are fully borrowed. As a result, they temporarily rely on AI tools to generate study notes on the topic: “factors causing the shift of the supply curve”. This scenario highlights how students may turn to AI tools as an alternative learning resource when traditional materials are inaccessible, making prompt design and critical engagement especially important.

Structured Prompt and Methodologically Sound AI Output
Jabulani asked ChatGPT: “Can you please list 3 main factors causing the shift of supply curve?” ChatGPT responded with a brief explanation of the following factors:
  • Cost of production: Higher input costs reduce supply (shift left), while lower costs increase supply (shift right).
  • Technology: Improved technology increases supply (shift right), while outdated production methods reduce supply (shift left).
  • Expectations about future prices: Expected higher future prices may reduce current supply (shift left), while expected lower future prices may increase current supply (shift right).
While correct, the explanation remains relatively brief and lacks deeper conceptual clarity and applied illustration.

Human-Led Refinement and External Validation
Isabella used a more detailed and structured prompt: “Can you please explain the 3 main factors causing the shift of supply curve, namely (1) cost of production, (2) technology and (3) expectations about future price? In your answers, please explain clearly when supply shifts leftward and rightward.” ChatGPT then produced a more comprehensive response, including definitions, directional shifts, and real-world examples:
  • Cost of production: Rising costs reduce supply (shift left), while falling costs increase supply (shift right), illustrated with examples such as wheat production and electricity costs.
  • Technology: Technological breakdowns reduce supply, while technological improvements increase supply, such as automation in production processes.
  • Expectations about future price: Producers may withhold supply if future prices are expected to rise, or increase current supply if prices are expected to fall, with examples such as maize storage and fishery sales behaviour. 
This improved output demonstrates how specific and structured prompts lead to more academically useful AI-generated explanations.

Final Outcome: Strengthening Conceptual Understanding Through Structured AI Use
The comparison between the two AI outputs demonstrates that:
  • Vague prompts produce brief and less developed explanations
  • Structured prompts generate more detailed, conceptually rich, and example-driven explanations
  • AI can support learning effectively when used with clear academic intent and guidance
  • Even in the absence of textbooks, AI outputs must still be critically evaluated for completeness and accuracy
The final outcome highlights that students can enhance learning outcomes by improving how they engage with AI tools. 

Implications for Teaching and Research Practice
This example demonstrates how AI can be effectively integrated into Economics learning under real-world constraints:
  • AI can serve as a temporary learning support tool when textbooks are unavailable
  • Prompt design becomes a key academic skill in shaping learning outcomes
  • Students develop awareness of the importance of depth, clarity, and structure in explanations
  • Lecturers play a critical role in validating and reinforcing disciplinary knowledge
This reinforces the idea that AI should be positioned as a supportive learning tool that requires active student judgement, academic oversight, and critical engagement, rather than a replacement for formal learning resources.  

Contact the CIECT team to assist with the design of your interactive online environment.




Post a Comment

Powered by Blogger.