AIColloquium
AI-Proofing Higher Education: From Product to Process - presented by Nabil Yasien Mohamed [Faculty of Arts and Humanities]
Wednesday, November 18, 2026As part of the CIECT AI Colloquium 2026, Mr Nabil Yasien Mohamed, Lecturer in Islamic Studies in the Department of Religion & Theology, presented on “AI-Proofing Higher Education: From Product to Process.” Mr Mohamed is the author of Ghazālī's Epistemology: A Critical Study of Doubt and Certainty and has research interests spanning classical Islamic philosophy and theology, contemporary Islamic thought, epistemology, ethics and ecology.
Drawing on his academic background in theology and professional experience in engineering, his presentation offered a critical perspective on Generative AI, arguing that higher education must actively safeguard genuine human inquiry by prioritizing the rigorous process of learning over easily fabricated final products.
Video Recording: https://youtu.be/eFztw4Ph4Rc?si=PhRfFqe2Wa7K_w5b
When AI Can Produce the Product
Generative AI can instantly fabricate essays, summaries, explanations, presentations and other forms of academic output. Mr Mohamed highlighted this as a fundamental threat to the integrity of higher education. When assessment focuses primarily on a final written product, it becomes nearly impossible to determine whether genuine learning took place in the student or whether a machine simply simulated it. This reality demands a decisive shift away from evaluating hollow outputs.
From Product to Process
A process-focused approach counters the shortcuts offered by AI by placing strict attention on how students arrive at their conclusions, rather than accepting a final answer at face value. Students must be required to document their research, wrestle with ideas, scrutinize sources, revise their work and defend the intellectual decisions they made along the way. Making the learning journey visible ensures that students cannot outsource their education to automated tools.
Showing the Thinking Behind the Work
While Generative AI can produce a superficially polished response, a polished surface masks the absence of real human comprehension. Process-oriented learning insists that students prove their own reasoning and intellectual development. This requires concrete evidence of human engagement—such as research notes, rough drafts, critical reflections, discussions, presentations and oral explanations—demonstrating that the student genuinely wrestled with the subject matter. The emphasis shifts from simply asking “What did you produce?” - to demanding - “Can you prove and defend how you developed this?”
Knowledge, Understanding and Critical Thinking
Higher education is not a mechanical exercise in assembling text. Students need to cultivate the discipline to question claims, evaluate evidence, discern truth from error and construct their own understanding. Because Generative AI routinely generates plausible-sounding falsehoods and bypasses intellectual struggle, uncritical reliance on it undermines the core purpose of university study. Preserving rigorous critical thinking requires resisting automated answers in favor of authentic human judgment.
The Role of Assessment
The proliferation of AI exposes the vulnerabilities of traditional, product-based assessment. Rather than relying on a single final submission that can easily be offloaded to an algorithm, educators must design assessments that track intellectual development over time. Requiring students to justify their choices, walk through their research steps, respond to critique and articulate their reasoning in real time restores accountability to the learning process.
AI and Epistemology
Mr Mohamed's background in epistemology—and specifically classical inquiries into doubt, certainty and the foundations of knowledge—underpins his deeply skeptical view of AI in education. Epistemology concerns how we truly know what we claim to know and what makes knowledge reliable. Generative AI is fundamentally detached from truth, comprehension and lived reality; it merely predicts patterns of words without understanding or epistemic accountability. Treating machine-generated output as a valid substitute for human inquiry erodes scholarly standards and encourages passive imitation over genuine certainty.
Ethics and Responsibility
The intrusion of AI into higher education also raises serious ethical concerns regarding intellectual honesty, authorship and moral agency. In Mr Mohamed's view, academic work carries an ethical weight that cannot be delegated to a machine. When students rely on AI to think or write on their behalf, they abdicate their responsibility as authors and learners. Upholding academic integrity requires resisting the normalization of AI shortcuts and reaffirming that true scholarship demands personal effort and accountability.
Preparing Higher Education for AI
For Mr Mohamed, “AI-proofing” higher education means actively defending the human intellect against technological displacement. Rather than reshaping curricula to accommodate AI tools, universities must double down on learning experiences where independent thinking, deep reading, questioning and intellectual struggle remain non-negotiable. As automated tools flood the academic landscape with synthetic text, higher education must stand firm in protecting the irreducibly human processes of study and discovery.
Mr Mohamed's presentation challenged the UWC community to confront the risks that Generative AI poses to authentic scholarship and intellectual formation. While machines can mimic a final product, they cannot replicate the cultivation of wisdom, judgement, reasoning and genuine understanding. The defining question for educators is therefore not “How can we incorporate AI into student work?”, but “How do we ensure that students are actually doing the thinking themselves?”
CIECT thanks Mr Nabil Yasien Mohamed for contributing to the AI Colloquium 2026 and for challenging the UWC community to protect academic integrity and meaningful human learning by shifting our focus from product to process.
.png)
.png)
.png)
Post a Comment